Sunday, May 22, 2005

Updating the iPod’s Firmware Requires Power Adapter for USB users

As an owner of an iPod for about two years now (first a 40GB 3rd generation, and now a 60GB iPod Photo), and having performed many software/firmware upgrades on my iPod in the past, I was stunned after upgrading my iPod Photo the other day, that after the upgrade, it insisted on being plugged into the wall in order to complete the update. I had never seen that before. What was different? I was using USB instead of FireWire.

Apparently during the writing of the new update to the firmware the iPod requires more power than USB can offer. My guess is some computers could power it fine over USB, but the USB standard is lax about power requirements, and some computers offer less power than others across their USB bus.

While the instructions after the firmware updater are run, and the graphic that appears on the iPod imply you MUST use the wall power adapter, I’ve found that connecting the iPod to my car cigarette lighter adapter, and to my computers 6 pin FireWire port also allowed it to flash its firmware successfully. So apparently it is only 4pin FireWire and USB connections that require an alternate power source.

This was a problem for me, however, as I normally carry my iPod around without the power adapter, or FireWire cable when I’m traveling, as my home laptop is a PowerBook, but my work/travel laptop is a Windows machine that I connect to via USB. Luckily I was able to connect it to someone’s car charger while I was traveling to complete the update, however, I think Apple should put a large orange sticker on the USB cable included with the iPod warning users that you could be stuck with a non-working iPod if you travel with only the USB cable and NOT the power adapter, and choose to do a software update. They should at least, when running the updater software, warn the user they will need a power adapter to complete the firmware update. They allow you to run the update enough off of USB to disable your iPod, but not restore it.

Anyway, here is the graphic on the iPod screen you will be presented with when you do a firmware update, and do not have a power adapter:


The safest thing to do, I guess, is never do a firmware update when traveling without your power adapter.

I found some discussions about this here as well: iPodlounge

4 comments:

Dread Pirate Robert said...

Oh. I just discovered this interesting fact myself. I guess I have to stare silently at that little graphic until I get more power.

Sheesh, not one single iPod user here at work has a power cable either.

Aric said...

Someone has pointed me to this blog entry which claims to have a work-around. I haven't tried it, so use it at your own peril.

http://www.bearsdriving.com/blog/archives/2005/10/your_ipod_tip_o.html

Zoftwar said...

I ran the iPod restore. When I plug the iPod with my AC Adapter. It still shows me the "plug into a wall" icon, just like the iPod won´t recognize it.

Robert F. Crocker said...

I was very impressed by this post, this blog has always been pleasant information 300W AC/DC Switching Adapter